Battery
Comparison
Rechargeable Battery Type Comparison
For a range of common types (non rechargeable cells are shown for comparison purposes):
| Battery Type |
Nominal
Cell Voltage |
Relative
Capacity |
Use In High Current
Devices
|
Recharge |
Number
Recharge
Cycles |
Self
Discharge
Rate |
Notes |
| Alkaline - Standard |
1.5V |
Medium |
Poor |
No |
n-a |
Slow (>5yrs) |
|
| Alkaline - High Power |
1.5V |
High |
Good |
No |
n-a |
Slow (>5yrs) |
|
| Alkaline - Rechargeable |
1.5V |
High* |
Poor |
Yes |
50-100 |
Slow (>5yrs) |
Not recommended. Capacity
reduces with use. |
| Carbon Zinc |
1.5V |
Low |
Poor |
No |
n-a |
Slow (>5yrs) |
Very old |
| Sealed Lead Acid |
2.1V |
High |
Good |
Yes |
500-800 |
Med (3%/m) |
Most commonly associated with car batteries but also available in sealed variants and smaller sizes. Not available in AA, AAA, C, D, PP3 sizes |
| Lithium |
3.6V |
High |
Good |
No |
n-a |
Slow (>10yrs) |
Do not confuse with Lithium
Ion batteries which are rechargeable. Not available in AA, AAA, C, D, PP3 sizes |
| Lithium Ion |
3.7V |
High |
Good |
Yes |
400-1200 |
Fast (8%/m) |
Not available in AA, AAA, C, D, PP3 sizes |
| Nickel Cadmium (NiCad) |
1.2V |
Medium |
Good |
Yes |
Up to 800 |
Fast (10%/m) |
Almost replaced by NiMH |
| Nickel Metal Hydride (NiMH) |
1.2V |
High |
Good |
Yes |
Up to 1000 |
Fast (25%/m) |
Now the most common type of rechargeable battery |
| Nickel Metal Hydride (NiMH) - Low Self Discharge |
1.2V |
High |
Good |
Yes |
Up to 1000 |
Medium (2%/m) |
|
| Nickel Zinc |
1.65 |
High |
Good |
Yes |
Up to 1000 |
??? |
CUrrently AA & AAA only, relatively high voltage not suitable for all devices |
| Zinc Chloride |
1.5V |
Low |
Poor |
No |
n-a |
Slow (>5yrs) |
Not available in AA, AAA, C, D, PP3 sizes |
|
Notes:
1. Number of Recharge cycles: How many times the
battery can be recharged.
2.
Achieving the number of cycles with
NiCads requires draining
the battery occasionally.
3.
Achieving the number of cycles with NiMH
requires shallow discharging (charging before the battery loses too
much power).
4. Self Discharge Rate: How quickly the batteries
lose their charge when left unused. Discharge is faster
at higher temperatures.
5. Self discharge rates are quoted at 20 degrees centigrade and increase significantly as the temperature increases.
6. Rechargeable batteries must be recharged
using the correct type of charger.
Battery Capacity Comparison
For a range of common types and sizes.
| Battery Type |
AAA |
AA |
C |
D |
PP3 |
| Alkaline - Standard |
960mAh |
2375mAh |
6500mAh |
12500mAh |
480mAh |
| Alkaline - High Power |
1150mAh |
2850mAh |
7800mAh |
15000mAh |
580mAh |
| Nickel Metal Hydride (NiMH) |
1100mAh |
2900mAh |
5000mAh |
10000mAh |
300mAh |
| Nickel Metal Hydride (NiMH) - Low Self Discharge |
800mAh |
2000mAh |
3000mAh |
6000mAh |
155mAh |
|
Notes:
1. Capacity is rated in either milli Amp hours (mAH) or Amp hours
(AH).
2. All capacities quoted are the highest capacity,
cheaper batteries will have lower capacities.
3. The capacity of alkaline batteries can be higher than the equivalent
NiMH but the capacity drops under high load.
4. The capacity of NiMH batteries does not reduce significantly under
high load.
|